whodunnit blog

SPOILER WARNING! 

.

.

.

SPOILER BELOW! If you don’t want to reveal the answer to Case File #1 just yet, scroll all the way down to the bottom of the page - this is your last warning!

.

.

.

And here it is. The one who committed the Murder At Mr. MacAbrey’s Mansion is…

Jay MaPall! The butler! Remember, back in Part 8, Jay MaPall wipes his brow with a black handkerchief – the same black handkerchief can be seen stuffed in Dorothy’s mouth. It was used to gag her, to prevent her from screaming while she was strangled with her own blue scarf. Once this is figured out the police are called, and Jay MaPall is arrested.

So there you have it, the end of Case File #1. But stay tuned – Case File #2 is right around the corner, so check back soon!